The NY Times published a great article yesterday about “saver’s remorse” where frugal-minded people like myself find ourselves feeling like we missed out on some of life’s greater pleasures.
The author goes so far as to interview consumer psychologists who cleverly refer to this condition as financial hyperopia (aka – farsightedness), where we’re looking so far into our financial future that we’re not living for today.
Almost makes me want to shout out Carpe Diem! and go rent The Dead Poet’s Society all over again.
I can honestly say I occasionally suffer from saver’s remorse, or the so called hyperopia.
For example, I never went on the infamous Spring Break trips to Cancun trips like most of my college friends. So when they would get back and tell their stories, I would feel a little left out because I missed out on events like Kenny doing a high dive from the 3rd floor hotel balcony or Maria getting felt up by a dirty old man at Senior Frogs. I’m told both stories involved copious amounts of (overpriced) alcohol, but still, I regret not seeing these events for myself instead of being told about them after the fact.
However, I like to think the $750 or more I saved by avoiding those trips allowed me to buy books, pay my rent, or at the very least, stay solvent and avoid credit card debt.
These days, I’m doing pretty well because I didn’t allow nearsightedness (myopia) to alter my long term financial goals. So I view my hyperopic tendencies with some ambivalence.
After all, the money I saved helped me buy a home at age 25, buy some pretty killer stocks that paid off very well, and I get to write my net worth with a black pen instead of one with red ink.
However, I’m not shy to say I spend money on certain everyday items I deem worth the investment. Such as:
I’m sure there are thousands of ways that people use to cope with their frugality, but it’s important to remember that behavior is one of the key personality quirks that affects our personal finances.
Staying apprised of the psychology of spending, whether it’s spending too much or spending too little, will definitely help your financial situation but can also help your emotional health over the long run.
As for me, my excessive saving and hyperopia has helped me over the course of my lifetime… like it was supposed too.
How about you? Do you suffer from hyperopia or saver’s remorse? How do you cope with it?
~~~
Photo by Shahram Sharif
@ Abigail
Small amounts of dark chocolate and alcohol (especially red wine) are supposedly healthy things. : ) We’ve all heard of red wine & resveratrol by now, but dark chocolate has copious amounts of flavenoids which lower blood pressure and LDL (bad cholesterol).
I would say I occasionally have hyperopia. Like right now, with the prices of houses so low I’d LOVE to buy a house, but it’s just not the right time for us. Other than that, I really feel like most of my frugality is really worth it. I’m still pretty young, so I feel like I’ll be in a good spot to relax a little soon enough – all because I’m being extra-careful right now.
@ Nicki,
Being extra-careful is a good thing! I wish more people had your financial foresight.
I think the big trade off with buying a house (regardless of the discounted value) is how much of your income can you guarantee to give to someone else over a 15 to 30 year time period. Somehow, this annoying little question seems to have fallen through the cracks in the last decade.
BTW: Great article this week in the Festival of Frugality.
I tend to overthink purchases, but the upside is that I never regret buying or not buying. We make sure we always have enough money for travel. But things–they always turn up again.
@ Frugalscholar
I’m the same way. I would rather have saver’s remorse than buyer’s remorse. I may regret not buying something or taking a killer vacation, but at least I still have the money which will likely cheer me back up.
Thanks for the great article and I enjoy your honesty. One point about your dog – research shows that the health benefits (reduced stress, healthier blood pressure levels, increased exercise) of owning a pet are excellent. Maybe what you save on stress and high blood pressure related doctors visits outweighs the cost of the new laptop cable? And like you say, you get a good (priceless!) laugh out of most of your dogs antics afterall!
Absolutely Julia! On paper, Sassie is a horrible investment.
Alternatively, if you included how many smiles and laughs I get out of her everyday, plus the forced exercise we get with a minimum of a half mile walk everyday, the “bad investment” argument falls apart pretty quick.
Personally, I’m content with saying she’s worth it, and then some!
I’m completely the opposite – I have regret over all the stuff I have bought needlessly. I’m currently selling a slew of items on ebay each with the disciprtion “like new” or “hardly used.”
I have a barely used ipad, a road bike, and many other items. And after recently listening to “Your Money or Your Life” I can to the stark realisation that my spending was out of control, and I was trying, but failing, to make myself happy with material things.
I actually found your blog by searching Google for “the things you own end up owning you”, which is from the film Fight Club.
Thanks for the info – it is useful!
Thanks LG. I definitely hear ya on the buyers remorse.
I occasionally get this from other things I buy, mainly tech gadgets (Xbox ranks pretty high in this category considering it’s been in a storage box for 2-3 years now), so I know where you’re coming from.
I try to ask myself: 1) can I use it everyday, 2) will it provide significant (real, not perceived) productivity in my life, 3) will the joy I get from the purpose fall victim to the law of diminishing returns.
My debt calendar post has done very well. I get a few emails every month from people who say it completely changed their views on consumerism, so I’m glad to have come up with an in-your-face graphic to burn the image of debt in their brains. Every time I’m about to take on a large, recurring debt, this calendar pops in my head, so I know firsthand how anti-consumer it can be.
Whether that’s a good thing or a bad thing depends upon your point of view.
Thanks again for the kind words.
3:17 am
I have to constantly battle the urge to pay down debt with enjoying myself a bit in the present. My husband helps keep me honest in this regard — he’s more of a spender. On the other hand, I help balance him out in the savings department.
I get some junk food from time to time. Chocolate is always a good way to enjoy the present, health repercussions aside.
Other times, we dole out $15 or so for some alcohol and have a friend or two over for a movie night.